What’s Best for Your Business Growth?
If you’re wondering whether to put your podcast on YouTube, or maybe you’re trying to decide which platform to focus on, this is the clarity you’ve been waiting for. The podcast vs YouTube for visibility debate is real, and knowing which one will actually support your growth can save you time, energy, and a whole lot of stress.Here’s the bottom line: YouTube and podcasting are both powerful visibility tools, but they work completely differently. Understanding how they function, and how they connect with audiences, can help you choose the right approach for your business.
Podcasting vs YouTube: What’s the Real Difference?
Let’s get one thing straight… saying “I have a podcast on YouTube” is a bit misleading. You either have a podcast (audio, distributed via podcast apps), or you have a YouTube channel. If you’re recording a video and uploading it to YouTube, that’s YouTube content, not a podcast.
Both formats are long-form and designed to build visibility, but the delivery and audience experience are completely different.
YouTube: The Search-Driven, Performance-Oriented Platform
YouTube is built for discovery. It’s one of the largest search engines in the world (right after its parent company, Google). When you create content optimized for search and thumbnails, YouTube can help you reach a whole new audience.
But here’s the catch…it’s very performance-based (in my honest opinion after trying it). You need to hold attention visually, have a compelling thumbnail, use fast-paced delivery, and stay camera-ready. That doesn’t mean it’s a bad platform…I might go back to it one day. It just means it’s a lot of work and needs its own strategy..
Also, a “view” on YouTube doesn’t mean someone stuck around. They might’ve clicked for a second and bounced. You’re competing with suggested videos, autoplay, and short attention spans. It’s a lot.
Podcasting: The Connection-Driven, Intimacy-Focused Platform
Podcasting is about trust and connection. When someone puts in their earbuds and hears your voice, it’s intimate. You become part of their daily routine. Whether they’re walking the dog, doing dishes, or driving to pick up the kids.
Listeners choose your show because of your content, not because of flashy thumbnails. You’re in their ears, uninterrupted. That depth of connection is powerful and much harder to replicate on video.
When your goal is to build relationships and nurture potential clients, podcasting often works faster and more effectively than a YouTube strategy.
The Biggest Mistake Creators Make
Many people record a video for YouTube, strip the audio, and upload it to podcast platforms without editing. That’s what I can’t stand. Listeners can instantly tell the episode wasn’t made for them when you say things like “in this video” or reference visuals they can’t see. As soon as I hear someone talking to the people watching on YouTube, they’ve lost my connection. They are no longer talking to me, they are talking at me. There’s a difference.
That disconnect breaks trust. If you’re going to repurpose, do it with intention. Either record separate versions for each platform, or rework your script to suit both formats.
Which Should Come First: Podcast or YouTube?
Ask yourself these questions:
- Do you want to be seen more (YouTube) or heard more deeply (podcasting)?
- Are you prepared to chase an algorithm (YouTube), or do you want long-term loyalty and trust (podcasting)?
- Do you want to build content from connection, or (don’t hate me…) performance?
If your business is built on personal connection, coaching, or service-based offers, podcasting should be your foundation. It lets your audience get to know you, like you, and trust you.
Once you’ve built that foundation, then you can layer in YouTube. But trying to do both from the start? That’s a fast track to burnout.
How to Repurpose the Right Way
You can absolutely use both platforms, but do it intentionally.
Here’s how:
- Podcast First Strategy: Record your podcast episode. Then, outline a separate script or idea for a YouTube video based on that same topic. Record the video with a YouTube-first strategy (pacing, visuals, hooks, etc.). If you record video while podcasting, that is fine, just know that you will not be growing on YouTube at the speed you would hope for.
- YouTube First Strategy: If YouTube is your primary platform, record there. Then repurpose the message (not the audio) for your podcast. Don’t just copy and paste. Edit with your podcast listener in mind.
Don’t mix the platforms. They require different tones, pacing, and call to actions. Speak directly to the person consuming the content, not just to a camera or a crowd.
So… Podcast or YouTube?
If you want to:
- Build deep, meaningful relationships
- Keep content creation simple
- Focus on connection over clicks
…Podcasting should be your first stop.
If you love being on camera, feel energized by performance, and enjoy creating visual content – YouTube could be a great next step. But remember: YouTube is a beast. It takes strategy, cameras, lighting, thumbnails, titles, editing, and consistency.
Choose what fits your energy and your audience. But don’t feel pressured to be everywhere. Be where you’re most effective.
Your podcast is more than just content. It’s the trust builder, the lead generator, and the heart of your brand. So start there. Build it strong. And then grow from that solid foundation.
Keep creating those episodes that move your listeners one step closer to becoming your clients. You’ve got this.
RELATED EPISODES
APPLY HERE
- Profitable Podcast VIP Day – a 1:1 experience where we audit your show, map your listener journey, and build a strategy designed to turn listeners into paying clients!
FREE RESOURCES
- Get Your Next 20 Episodes
- Quiz: What’s Keeping Your Podcast from Growing?
- 7 Podcast Metrics to Track and How to Track Them
- Private Podcast: Are You Ready for a Podcast? 5 Steps You Need to Take BEFORE You Record
- Listen to the podcast: Podcast-First Marketing
PODCAST RESOURCES:
- Podcast Hosting: Captivate (7-day free trial with my affiliate link)
- Referral Link for Descript
- Website & Blog through Showit
- Email Marketing with Flodesk
*Some links shared may contain affiliate links in which I do receive a very small commission.
LEAVE A COMMENT